There are lots of reasons people have a different derech, including abuse, but also including things like having different goals in life, non-belief, lack of support in school, etc.
The reasons people are no longer observant is different for everyone. (Which probably makes it really scary for some parents to accept). Non-observant people aren't all the same.
Recipe Tagged0 Hug8 Like
Ravenclaw
Tue, Feb 18 2025, 1:23 am
Here’s the thing. I know many ppl in the OTD community and will say based on what I’ve seen, most have gone through abuse.
But I don’t like saying it. Because people use that as an excuse to kind of invalidate the experience of ppl who choose to go OTD.
But I see it differently.
Here we are blaming those who go OTD when they are forced to heal outside the community because of the way we have structured things. Many of them build genuinely happy and healthy lives, and meanwhile those who abused them are still frum and have the community’s respect.
Here’s the thing. I know many ppl in the OTD community and will say based on what I’ve seen, most have gone through abuse.
But I don’t like saying it. Because people use that as an excuse to kind of invalidate the experience of ppl who choose to go OTD.
But I see it differently.
Here we are blaming those who go OTD when they are forced to heal outside the community because of the way we have structured things. Many of them build genuinely happy and healthy lives, and meanwhile those who abused them are still frum and have the community’s respect.
Makes you think.
Yes. Makes sense
Recipe Tagged0 Hug0 Like
jkl
Tue, Feb 18 2025, 1:48 am
Ravenclaw wrote:
Here’s the thing. I know many ppl in the OTD community and will say based on what I’ve seen, most have gone through abuse.
But I don’t like saying it. Because people use that as an excuse to kind of invalidate the experience of ppl who choose to go OTD.
But I see it differently.
Here we are blaming those who go OTD when they are forced to heal outside the community because of the way we have structured things. Many of them build genuinely happy and healthy lives, and meanwhile those who abused them are still frum and have the community’s respect.
Makes you think.
Quite a few of them have gone OTD because of our school system, especially boys. If they don't have gemara kups, even if they are quite intelligent, they are made to feel less than.
Same for kids who are artsy or anyone out of the box. We don't make place for them in our communities.
Quite a few of them have gone OTD because of our school system, especially boys. If they don't have gemara kups, even if they are quite intelligent, they are made to feel less than.
Same for kids who are artsy or anyone out of the box. We don't make place for them in our communities.