# What Happened to the 160 Lev Tahor Children?

- Outlet: What Happened to the 160 Lev Tahor Children?
- Author: Mariela Castañón; Carlos Gutiérrez Bracho
- Date: 2015-02-01
- URL: https://www.connectas.org/especiales/ninos-lev-tahor/index_en.html
- Retrieved via: live on 2026-11-18
- Language: en
- Words: 5308

---

This page has several elements with audio

In 2024, during a mega-operation of international impact, dozens of children from this ultra-Orthodox Jewish community were forcibly separated from their families in Guatemala. The aim, according to the authorities, was to rescue them from alleged sexual abuse and other types of mistreatment.

However, their relatives allege that they experienced various episodes of violence inside the shelters. There are even (at least) two reports of sexual assault against minors by public servants.

After almost 15 months, they all returned to their families, to a dissolved community. Most went into exile.

The history of the Lev Tahor (pure heart, in Hebrew) ultra-Orthodox Jews is marked by constant migration and expulsions from countries such as the United States, Mexico, Canada and, recently, Colombia. Some media outlets call them "Jewish Taliban" due to the numerous accusations, and even prison time, for some of their leaders for sexual offenses, trafficking, and kidnapping of minors. The accusations include promoting child marriages, as well as neglecting the health and hygiene of their children.

Lev Tahor arrived in Guatemala more than a decade ago. One of its most notorious scandals in the international press occurred in this country: on December 20, 2024, security forces and other entities conducted a huge operation in the village of El Amatillo, department of Santa Rosa. According to authorities, they rescued 160 girls, boys, and teenagers from possible sexual assaults within the same community.

They had an arrest warrant against a 24-year-old Salvadoran identified on social media and in the media as the "alleged leader" of Lev Tahor in Guatemala. Four teenagers who escaped from that group had reported him to the Public Ministry for alleged sexual offenses.

Before the judge who authorized that deployment, the assistant prosecutor of the Public Ministry referred to the opinion of an expert from the INACIF (National Institute of Forensic Sciences), a specialist who verified physical signs of sexual abuse against one of these four minors, with "a broomstick in the anus", among other practices.

At the hearing before the judge in 2024, the assistant prosecutor also urgently requested the search, inspection, registration and seizure of evidence in the village. The fear was that other minors were also being victimized by sexual crimes such as abuse and child or youth pornography.

During the mega-operation, the Salvadoran was not in El Amatillo. He was captured in El Salvador days later and extradited to Guatemala, where he remained, as of the closure of this investigation, in preventive detention for the crimes of mistreatment and rape against minors.

The events, however, did not occur as publicly reported. This journalistic work by Nuestras Historias, CONNECTAS, Plaza Pública, Ruda and Prensa Comunitaria presents documents and testimonies that cast doubt on whether there were excesses and negligence on the part of the Guatemalan authorities in this case.

The first of these is the official report from the Public Ministry on the mega-operation, obtained for this journalistic investigation. It reveals that during the intervention no evidence was found that any of those 160 minors had been victims of sexual abuse or pornography.

Second, the same family members claim that these girls, boys, and adolescents who were placed in the care of the State suffered different types of violence in the group homes where they remained institutionalized for between 4 and almost 15 months. In fact, there are at least two complaints filed with the Public Ministry for alleged sexual assaults on a child and a teenager by workers, which, as of the closure of this investigation, had not been resolved by the competent authorities.

The children were returned to their families on the condition that their parents attend a Parents' School, a program that teaches them to raise their children with love and respect, and that they take them to live in places with conditions suitable for their well-being. But they could not return to their community in El Amatillo, since the judges ordered them not to be together again, according to testimonies from the families themselves. In addition, they asked parents to improve the care they provide to their daughters and sons.

Investigations are still ongoing. Via a WhatsApp message, the Social Communication office of the Prosecutor General's Office (PGN) reported that "all the children are with family. Some are in Guatemala, others in the United States, and others in Israel. It is also known that one of the women left the country with her children, despite a court order mandating otherwise, thus evading the legal process, and is allegedly in Ecuador.” To date, 42 minors remain in Guatemala.

Uriel Goldman's family is one of those that left Guatemala. He shared a video on July 31, 2025, when his wife, Liba, was leaving the courthouse after regaining custody of her children.

He accompanied it with the following message before leaving the country: “They are already outside. They will go to the house for a few minutes. We only rented it for seven months. We bought beds for all the children. Now we're going to leave everything behind and start over. That's a small problem, because now we have the children, and my wife is going to travel to the airport right away.”

This investigation shows how tensions between the Lev Tahor and Guatemalan authorities left the children in the middle of a dispute full of stigmatization, clashes between Jews and authorities, accusations of sexual violence and accusations from both sides.

The Lev Tahor organization appears in the registry of religious entities of the Ministry of the Interior under the name of Asociación Jajme Bovel Guatemala. It has been embroiled in controversy since its inception.

Rabbi Shlomo Helbrans founded it in Jerusalem in 1988, with the promise to practice a Judaism adhering to the original doctrine, and two years later he moved to the United States. In 1993 he was convicted of kidnapping an American teenager and was granted parole in 1996. He then took refuge in Canada with his community, and later arrived in Mexico, where he died.

He was succeeded by his son Nachman, who is currently serving a 12-year prison sentence in New York for kidnapping two of his nephews. Recently, a couple of members of the community were extradited from Guatemala to Mexico for their possible involvement in human trafficking for child marriages.

One of the main accusations against Lev Tahor is precisely that they practice teenage marriage, which is prohibited in several nations. In fact, in Guatemala it is penalized under any circumstances.

For this community, however, this prohibition is a religious dilemma, because they live based on the Torah, as explained by Iván Cherjovsky, an academic at the University of Buenos Aires and a member of the Center for Jewish Studies/IDES. For Orthodox Jews, the researcher states, teenagers can marry because a 13-year-old boy and a 12-year-old girl are already adults.

In an investigation into marriages in Judaism, researcher Cayetana H. Johnson, from the San Dámaso Ecclesiastical University of Madrid, explains that, in the context of biblical Israel, minors “are excluded from entering into marriage.” She refers exclusively to those who have not reached puberty.

Tensions between the Lev Tahor and the Guatemalan state reached their peak on December 20, when members of the special forces stormed into El Amatillo. They had permission to access all operating systems and electronic devices, under the suspicion that they contained child and youth pornography.

This is because the four teenagers who reported the Salvadoran's assaults said that Lev Tahor leaders forced them to record themselves having sex with their wives, who were also minors under Guatemalan law. According to their accounts, the goal was to ensure they became pregnant.

She also reports that they intervened in the community several times before the operation held in December, in order to verify the condition of the girls, boys and adolescents. In 2024, “we supported and promoted 18 personal inspections,” says Prera. But “the results were unsuccessful,” because the Lev Tahor Jews did not cooperate, so they could not know “whether the accusations against them were true or false.”

We consulted with Reyes Juárez about the reasons the Public Ministry had to take away the children. He explains that the Lev Tahor adults violated the right to identity of the minors, "by not indicating who their parents were, their name, nationality and also because of the complaints that the PGN had received, where they mentioned mistreatment, pregnancies and forced marriages."

The Public Ministry’s report details the magnitude of the operation on December 20: more than 400 members of the National Civil Police (PNC), agents of the Specialized Division for Criminal Investigation (DEIC), prosecutors and assistants of the MP, computer technicians and analysts, as well as 70 military personnel, patrols and trained dogs participated. Families report that helicopters flew overhead.

Reconstruction of the search, inspection, registration and seizure of evidence proceedings of December 20, 2024, according to the official report of the Public Ministry.

- Responsible
- Assistant prosecutor Juan Francisco Reyes Juárez.
- Date
- December 20, 2024.
- Start of the proceedings
- 6:02 am.
- End of proceedings
- 9:20 pm.
- Reason
- to investigate possible unlawful acts and reasons to suspect the existence of traces of the crime.
- Place
- Aldea El Amatillo.
- Location
- Kilometer 94.5, municipality of Oratorio, department of Santa Rosa. On the border with the department of Jutiapa, Guatemala.

- 426 members of the National Civil Police
- 70 officers and soldiers
- 51 assistant prosecutors
- 10 professionals in psychology
- 10 forensic investigation technicians
- 6 lawyers from the Prosecutor General's Office
- 4 members of the canine unit
- 3 canine specimens
- 2 IT support technicians
- 2 systems analyst
- 2 technical analysts from the Criminal Analysis Directorate
- 2 professionals from the Human Rights Ombudsman's Office
- 2 forensic investigation technicians

Note: an unspecified number of uniformed army personnel, female personnel from the National Civil Police, paramedic personnel from the National Civil Police, and technicians and analysts from the Child Protection System of the Attorney General's Office against Human Trafficking were also participating.

Authorities knock on the door and a man answers, he identifies himself as Joshua.

**The following are notified:**

- Search warrant, inspection, search and seizure of evidence.
- Order for review, extraction, preservation and analysis of information from devices.

Joshua voluntarily allows entry to the property without resistance.

**Property features:**

- Land and/or rural property.
- Guardhouse area with gray gate and bars.
- Common area or possible church.
- 14 rooms (where the residents possibly spend the night).
- Divisions of 51 rooms, each with household furnishings.
- Construction area at the back of the property.
- With an area used as a school, restroom and shower.
- A small farm.

**People present on the property, upon the authorities' entry**

- Approximately 28 males.
- Females, number not specified.
- Children and adolescents (NNA), number not specified.

The residents are preventing personnel from the National Civil Police, the Prosecutor General's Office, and the Public Ministry from speaking. They are asked their name, nationality, and role within the congregation. They start dancing, shouting, and singing.

Two lawyers arrive to defend the residents.

- One of them enters violently, recording and assaulting the staff of each of the institutions.
- He does not allow the National Civil Police to search him.
- He does not hand over his cell phone when asked.
- He is isolated and asked to remain calm during the proceedings.

Authorities enter the common area, where everyone is.

- The residents do not allow administrative and security personnel to enter.
- Male individuals assault staff members of the institutions, shouting and insulting them at all times.
- Personnel from the National Civil Police and the Prosecutor General's Office proceed to verify the health status of the children and adolescents.

Public forces separate adult men from women and children.

- Objective: to interview children and adolescents and provide them with victimology support.

The children and adolescents do not want to identify themselves; they just scream for no reason. Multidisciplinary staff from the Prosecutor General's Office transfer the children and adolescents to the competent jurisdictional or administrative body to provide them with victimology care.

Throughout the morning, the authorities split into five groups to inspect the entire El Amatillo farm.

A military colonel arrives at the farm with 70 people, including officers and soldiers. Besides:

- 1 agent, in charge of the UCR ASONBOMD team.
- 1 agent in charge of Breeding (sic).
- 4 members of the canine unit.
- 3 canine specimens.
- Uniformed members of the army, number unidentified.

They begin a search with canine units for possible human remains.

The official auxiliary of the Human Rights Ombudsman's institution arrives. Besides:

- 2 more professionals from that institution
- They ensure "that the rights and guarantees of all subjects are ensured."

An agent and the canine unit “Lucas” locate, in a wooded area, a possible grave with a wooden box containing possible bones.

The residents say they have legal permission for a cemetery. They are given one hour to present the documentation and the death certificate of the located child.

Two forensic investigation technicians arrive at the “crime scene” (sic). They proceed to pack up the evidence.

Assistant prosecutor of the Municipal Attorney's Office of Jalpatagua initiates the procedure for the removal of the body.

A resident presents an environmental license from 2023 that authorizes a private cemetery for the Jewish community. The issuer is the Director of Environmental Management and Natural Resources of the Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources.

**“REMOVAL OF THE BODY IS NOT PERMITTED.”**

A deputy commissioner is asked to voluntarily hand over his cell phone. Alleged messages have been found between people from this community and the deputy commissioner.

Arrest of the deputy commissioner for flagrant crime. Possible commission of the criminal offense of revealing secrets.

A metal container with cash is located:

- 24 five quetzal bills.
- 12 bills of 10 quetzales.
- 10 bills of 20 quetzales.
- 2 bills of 50 quetzales.
- Coins of various denominations.
- **Total: 562 quetzales and 25 cents.**

- 1 twenty-dollar bill.
- 1 five-dollar bill.
- 2 one dollar bills.
- **Total: $27**

The property is handed over to the residents' defense attorney in the same condition in which it was found. He receives it to his complete satisfaction.

Children and adolescents are placed under the care of their parents.

**“NO FIREARMS, TRACES OR ILLEGAL ITEMS WERE FOUND IN THE ENTIRE BUILT AND VACANT AREA.”**

“THEY DID NOT FIND ANY ILLEGAL ITEMS OR ITEMS CONSTITUTING A CRIME.”



News of the massive deployment of state forces in Guatemala had worldwide reach and was met with several exaggerations. For instance, the then Minister of the Interior, Francisco Jiménez, posted on X that the “operation allowed the rescue of 160 minors who were allegedly abused by a member of Lev Tahor,” without evidence that any of those children had been victims of that alleged Jewish leader.

On the other hand, the MP's report also contradicts the original version that community members resisted authorities entering the property on December 20. According to reports, inside there were only "approximately" 28 men, as well as several women, girls, boys and teenagers, who ran to take refuge in the synagogue.

Liba Goldman, mother of eight children between the ages of 5 and 16; Miryam Rubin, mother of two girls; and Miriam Rosner, mother of six children between the ages of 2 and 11, recount how they experienced the raid on December 20, 2024.

According to the Public Ministry’s document, when the authorities asked them their name, nationality and role within the congregation, the Lev Tahor “started dancing, shouting and singing”. They did not allow us to check the health status of the minors, who were "shouting for no reason", and therefore presumed that their safety could be at risk and tried to enter the synagogue. When they failed to achieve this, “with authorization from the highest authorities of each institution”, they resorted to the “public forces”. The goal was to "separate adult men from women and children."

Thus, 205 people—adult women and the 160 minors—were taken, first, to the facilities of the Prosecutor General's Office, then to a Justice of the Peace and, finally, to the Secretariat of Social Welfare (SBS, for its initials in Spanish) to be under the protection of the State.

In its report, the Public Ministry acknowledges that during the raid they found nothing illegal. They did not detect any child or youth pornography material, and in the entire village there was only the equivalent of 100 dollars in local currency, as well as simple documents with printed and handwritten writing, birth certificates, and a passport that was deemed irrelevant to the investigation.

Two days before the start of the institutionalization of minors in state protection centers, the Prosecutor General's Office reported that members of the Lev Tahor community "forced the gate" of the Alida España de Arana Special Education Center. They abducted minors and caused "them to spread out into nearby streets." The place was under the control of the Secretariat of Social Welfare. The Human Rights Ombudsman's Office (PDH) formed multidisciplinary teams to locate the missing girls, boys, and adolescents, according to a statement from the agency.

This incident resulted in the women and children being brought before a judge, who ordered them to be moved to Casa Nuestras Raíces, also run by the Secretariat of Social Welfare. Furthermore, he requested police surveillance, despite which several violent incidents occurred inside the place.

One of them began on January 7, because apparently the children protested about the food they were given. According to their religious beliefs, Orthodox Jews only eat kosher foods, which follow purity and preparation standards as dictated by their sacred scriptures.

The Secretariat of Social Welfare stated in a press release that, for three consecutive nights, Lev Tahor girls, boys, teenagers and adult women disturbed the peace, destroyed furniture and anything they found in their path. In addition, they attacked Secretariat of Social Welfare staff and police officers.

Families report that authorities sprayed them with tear gas in an attempt to control the situation. “Those were days of terror,” acknowledges Marvin Rabanales García, Secretary of Social Welfare, when speaking about what happened.

Later, Secretariat of Social Welfare personnel evicted the Lev Tahor mothers from Casa Nuestras Raíces and sent the minors to different shelters. A high-ranking source from the Court of First Instance for Children and Adolescents of the Metropolitan Area revealed, under anonymity, that during the eviction, the authorities mistook teenagers for adults and forcibly removed them.

Department of Special Protection of Early Childhood (Zacapa)

Specialized Program for Children and Adolescents Victims of Sexual Violence, Exploitation and Trafficking in Persons—Trafficking Guatemala II—

Specialized Program for Children and Adolescents Victims of Sexual Violence, Exploitation and Trafficking in Persons—Trafficking Guatemala I—

Department of Adolescent Care with Specialized Attention, Diamante I Residence

Source: Secretariat of Social Welfare of the Presidency of the Republic.

Liba Goldman says the expulsion was "miserable" because, in effect, the authorities threw minors out onto the street. “They grabbed anyone they thought was over 18 years old.” Her daughter was one of them and she was pregnant.

The Undersecretary of Protection and Care for Children and Adolescents of the Secretariat of Social Welfare, María José Ortiz Samayoa, acknowledges that it was very difficult to document people, since many use the same name or surname or have combinations that could lead to error.

“That night,” she recounts, “the teams in charge of separating people in each of the rooms where they were located carried a printed sheet with information on each of the women who appeared as adults to be removed from the premises. In other words, it was done against the record, one by one. It was an operation involving a significant number of personnel. There were approximately 150 people from the Secretariat of Social Welfare and 250 from the National Civil Police.”

Four days later, the Prosecutor General's Office activated Alba-Keneth Alerts, an inter-institutional system for the search, location and protection of missing or abducted children, for the disappearance of 12 Lev Tahor teenagers who were in the children's home. This is because "it carried out an official verification procedure, as part of the investigations derived from a complaint for violations of the human rights of children and adolescents" and the "whereabouts of these adolescents were unknown," according to the response via public information.

Furthermore, the undersecretary adds that the eviction occurred because, apparently, U.S. authorities intercepted the communication of a Lev Tahor leader detained in New York and deduced that the mothers would poison their children.

How did they intercept it? “We don’t know,” Rabanales García replies. The United States did that. "You'd have to ask them." To get their side of the story, we contacted the United States Embassy in Guatemala, but they did not respond to the request.

Two brothers who were institutionalized after the December 2024 operation recount in limited Spanish that at the home they were forbidden from eating the food their mother brought them because it could contain poison.

In an interview, Franck Steven Rios, rapporteur for the OPT (Metropolitan Region of the National Office for the Prevention of Torture), acknowledges that he was the one who asked the judges to evict the mothers and gives a different version about the origin of the poisoning threat.

He says his office received an anonymous tip, which allowed them to enter the shelter and interview supervisors and police officers, and that they were in contact with the Secretariat of Social Welfare and PGN personnel, in communication with the Embassy of Israel. They also relied on information obtained from the internet. “We have historical precedents for this type of community, which even the Israeli government has called a sect and which has suicidal tendencies.”

For its part, the Public Information Access Unit of the OPT responds that it was unaware of any complaint or document regarding the alleged intention of Jewish mothers to poison their children.

One of the expelled teenagers was the mother of Shloimer Alter, a baby who remained in stated care throughout his short life – lived for only22 days, and died on July 27, 2025. The death certificate states, without further explanation, that the cause was aspiration pneumonia. A relative who requested anonymity claims that they wanted him to be treated in a private hospital, not in the Hospital Regional de Occidente, and the authorities did not allow the transfer.

However, Undersecretary Ortiz Samayoa maintains that there was no negligence. “Viral diseases cannot be attributed to any kind of negligence because it is something that travels through the air,” she says. He also points out that Shloimer was treated at that public hospital because that is what the institutional protocol indicates.

Registration during the institutionalization period from December 20, 2024 to August 6, 2025

- Perianal abscess
- Oral ulcers
- Allergies
- Amygdalates
- Anemia
- Burning and tired eyes
- Bronchitis
- Change of lenses
- Oral Candida
- Caries
- Headache
- Tension headache
- Circumcision
- Nasal congestion
- Conjunctivitis
- Prenatal care
- Contusion on 5th finger, left hand
- Contusion, right hand
- Ankle contusion
- Dermatitis
- Seborrheic dermatitis
- Dehydration
- Diarrhea
- Difficulty seeing
- Dimenorrhea \[sic\]
- Abdominal pain
- Headache

- Foot pain
- Epigastric pain
- Acute stomach pain
- Pain from spinal malformation
- Lower back pain
- Moderate DPE Viral Pneumonia
- Abscess drainage
- Epidermis
- Epistaxis
- Constipation
- Stress
- Dental evaluation
- Neurological evaluation
- Psychiatric evaluation
- Tooth extraction
- Faringolaringotraqueitis
- Fever
- Finibitis \[sic\]
- Folliculitis
- Bacterial gastroenteritis
- Cutting wound
- Superinfected wounds
- Inguinal hernia
- Bullous impetigo \[sic\]
- Throat infection
- Skin infection

- Intestinal infection
- Influenza
- Insomnia
- Intolerance to dairy formulas
- Laboratories
- Nasal cavity lacerations
- Superficial lacerations
- Granulomatous lesion of the leg
- Soft tissue injury
- Skin lesions
- Dental cleaning
- Dental malformation
- Myopia dental fillings
- Loose molars
- Nebulization
- Pneumonia
- Nutrition
- Obsessive chin \[sic\]
- Odynographia \[sic\]
- Dry eye
- Onychomycosis
- Earache
- Otitis externa
- Stomach ailments
- Respiratory illnesses
- Paronychia

- Pediculoris \[sic\]
- Pedicles
- Weight loss
- Pregnancy tests
- First and second degree burns
- X Rays
- Chronic reflux
- Common cold
- Resonance
- Allergic rhinitis
- Rinofaringitis
- Nosebleed
- Nasal discharge
- Sedema in ankle \[sic\]
- Flu symptoms
- Suppurative ear
- Cerumus plug \[sic\]
- Productive cough
- Coughing and sneezing
- Labor
- Traumatology
- Ingrown toenail
- Urticaria
- Varicela
- Vaseline in the mouth
- Blurred vision

The families' lawyer, Darío Vásquez Pérez, shared with this team copies of the complaints that were filed in February 2025 by family members with the Attorney's Office against Human Trafficking of the Public Ministry. In one case, they allege that an 11-year-old boy was forced to have sex with workers, who hugged him and encouraged other children to harass him. The mother says she does not remember the place where her son was institutionalized, only that it is a place located in Zone 13.

“They (from the Secretariat of Social Welfare) were forcing him to do bad and dirty things, things that men do to women, things that only married couples know about, like when one of the men pulls down his pants and then the children run away when they see it because they don’t want to see the bad things,” the document reads.

Through a public request for information, the Public Ministry was asked to share its own copy of the document and to report on the status of this complaint. It argued that it was not in a position to do so "because it is confidential by legal provision”.

In another complaint, the alleged victim is a 15-year-old teenager, who was also allegedly sexually abused by staff members of the Secretariat of Social Welfare. It says as follows: “The Secretariat of Social Welfare people told my son to take off his pants, another example is that they tell him that nobody will see, they tell him 'nobody will see it, it's just you and me \[sic\]', they tell them to touch each other and do that between them until they finish.”

Both complaints were signed by the assistant prosecutor, as well as by a psychologist from the same Attorney's Office and by a sworn and certified translator.

These are not the only cases reported by families. In a written report shared with this reporting team, Vásquez Pérez describes several cases of children who were alleged victims of sexual assault, touching, and exposure to pornographic content also within the residences run by the Secretariat of Social Welfare. In one of the paragraphs, it says: “On one occasion, a Secretariat of Social Welfare employee was alone in the presence of three teenagers from the Lev Tahor community and in an act of abuse of power and inappropriate conduct proceeded to take off his pants and underwear in front of them while uttering expressions of a sexual nature such as 'let's fuck together, you're going to like this'.”

Undersecretary Ortiz Samayoa denies these versions: “That has not happened. The boys are not going to be shown pornography. If there were any specific complaint, we would initiate a specific disciplinary process and file a specific criminal complaint.”

In turn, in response to a public information request regarding possible criminal and legal actions for these alleged acts, the Secretariat of Social Welfare reported the "non-existence" of this type of complaint. Therefore, "it cannot initiate administrative proceedings against the workers."

The Guatemalan State uses institutionalization as a care mechanism to protect minors from violence or sexual abuse in their family environment. However, it has “a burden on its shoulders” because historically it has overused this measure, emphasizes Luis Pedernera, former president of the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child.

The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) warns that, in 2024 alone, it registered approximately 5,000 institutionalized children, even though 94% of them had a relative who could safely take them into their home.

For Anally Maldonado, coordinator of CONACMI (Care Center of the National Association Against Child Abuse), one of the social organizations in charge of the schools for parents, "the diet and cultural identity were not respected" in the process of protecting the 160 Lev Tahor minors. He adds that, instead of protecting the children, the authorities criminalized them. This “led to the separation of families for several months, which affected the mental health of the children, who showed symptoms of depression.”

In principle, “the aggressive intervention” in El Amatillo was legally justified, says Esteban Celada, general director of the Society of Professionals for Dignity and Justice (IUS Dignitas).

A high-level source in the Court of First Instance for Children and Adolescents in the Metropolitan area states, anonymously, that after the operation they verified some harm to the minors. For example, poor oral health, lack of a balanced and rigid diet, and they did not attend school because their academic training was limited to reading the Torah.

However, Celada criticizes that after the mega-operation there may have been abuse of authority and excessive use of criminal law for the protection of children's rights. “At the very least, they should have interviewed more than one of the direct victims” to avoid doubts about due process.

Yehuda (name changed, at the interviewee's request) is a tall, thin, distant, and serious man. Speaking in broken Spanish, he recounts that he was separated from his three children for 138 days. They were able to reunite because the judge found "nothing wrong" with him and his wife taking care of them.

Miriam's children were returned to her four months after the mega-operation, after she attended the school for parents. She rented a house away from the community and submitted the requested psychological reports. But a few weeks later, her children were taken away again because the Prosecutor General's Office considered them to be at risk and, to prove it, they took a picture when her three-year-old was walking near a railing on a second floor, and they presented it to the court.

The latter conditioned Miriam to look for a new space that would guarantee the safety of her children. She did so and she got back her family. She now rents an apartment on the first floor.

Almost a year after the mega-operation, the headlines shifted to Colombia, where on November 23, authorities arrested 26 Lev Tahor members from the United States and Panama. The group included 9 adults and 17 children, 5 of whom were subject to an Interpol yellow alert, "possible victims of human trafficking and kidnapping," the Colombian government said in an official statement. On December 1, it expelled the adults and placed the 17 minors in the custody of Child Protective Services in New York.

According to reports from Colombian Migration, “although all the children entered Colombia accompanied by at least one of their parents or relatives, it was noted that in some cases the adults do not have current legal custody due to orders from judicial and administrative authorities in the United States, a situation that triggered the Interpol preventive alert.”

In a press release on December 31, 2025, the NGO Valientes Colombia, which works to prevent and eradicate the trafficking of children and adolescents for commercial sexual exploitation, accused Colombian Migration of having a "false, stigmatizing and contradictory" narrative. This is because "these are families on the move who may require international protection, not a media fabrication." They emphasize that no crimes or mistreatment by members of the Lev Tahor community were proven, but that they were "sons and daughters of these families who were together and who \[...\] were fleeing the abusive control exercised by several leaders and their entourage."

As in Guatemala, the approach of the Colombian authorities was, firstly, coercive, instead of seeking to address the needs of children and adolescents and guarantee their rights. These stories show that, instead of receiving real protection of their most basic rights, Lev Tahor children have been forced to live their childhood amid legal, religious and political disputes, surrounded by prejudice and moral dilemmas.
