Ontario, Canada – Lev Tahor Members May Defy Judge’s Order To Turn 14 Kids Over To Foster Care

    46

    PHOTO COURTESY TO VINnews.com - Uriel Goldman from the Jewish sect Lev Tahor talks on his phone north of Chatham, Ont., on Tuesday, November 26, 2013. (TYLER BROWNBRIDGE/The Windsor Star)Ontario, Canada – According to news reports from the Montreal Gazette and the Windsor Star, a Quebec judge has ordered three couples who are members of the ultra-orthodox Jewish sect known as Lev Tahor to surrender their children to provincial child protection authorities.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    The 14 children, who range from two months to 16 years of age, will then be given medical examinations and placed in foster care.

    A Lev Tahor leader, however, told reporters that the parents have no intention of obeying the order, saying the judge has no authority over the families because they moved, along with some 200 other sect members, from Quebec to Ontario before youth protection officials could bring the matter before a judge.

    Lev Tahor members claimed they are being persecuted because of their beliefs and that children raised in the religious community are not neglected in any way.

    Youth protection investigators, on the other hand, claimed there was evidence of extreme neglect, malnutrition, and isolation when they inspected the children’s homes in Quebec. They also said the children, who are home schooled, cannot solve basic math problems or speak English or French.

    Even though the Lev Tahor families are now residing in Ontario, the regional head of youth protection services said it’s likely the Quebec court decision can be enforced by judicial authorities in Ontario.

    “Ontario authorities can take this decision now and get an order from a court,” said Denis Baraby, the director of youth protection services for the Laurentians.” We think there is a high possibility they will return them here.”

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group
    46 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    12 years ago

    Poor outcomes from naivite.

    basmelech
    basmelech
    12 years ago

    Our Bubbes and Zaidas in the shtetl didn’t speak Polish or Russian (English or French) either. The fact that the children don’t know too much English is not a reason to remove them from their parents. In der alt heim children weren’t taught secular subjects either. That is the way these people want to live and they are being persecuted because of it. The Amish also dress differently than most people and teach their children their way of life and they are not condemned for it so why is this group being singled out?

    itzik18
    itzik18
    12 years ago

    if it were a group of natives in Papua New Guinea, all of the bleeding heart liberals would want to help them preserve their culture – but here they want to force them to abandon their beliefs

    savtat
    savtat
    12 years ago

    To Number 2 – did the people in the alteh heim also have their daughters wear the burkah? Doesn’t seem so traditional to me. Looks like a new path not based on our traditions.

    leahle
    leahle
    12 years ago

    Really? My zayde spoke five languages. I can’t speak to the accuracy of the allegations, but from what I can tell, Lev Tahor is nothing like the Amish. The Amish, not only speak English, they manage to follow the law of the land while keeping their customs. They are educated in English, study math and history, though usually not science, and keep their children in school until 8th grade This is in accordance with a US Supreme Court decision that permitted the Amish to cease formal education at age 14. After that age, Amish children are taught a trade. The Amish very proudly support themselves and do not accept any government assistance. Does this in any way seem like Lev Tahor?

    WebDesign
    WebDesign
    12 years ago

    This is antisemitism at its highest peak!!

    As a Jew I know how important it is to understand that because someone dresses or thinks differently then you doesn’t mean that they are zombies & abusing all their children.

    For the survival of us all, we should be demonizing this behavior.

    I am disgusted by the self hating Anti-Semitism from many heimisha yidden.

    Suddenly everyone is worried about the health & education of these children, i can give you a list of 20+ countries where the children have a much worse life, and really need some sympathy.

    Our Grandparents in Poland didn’t speak a good Polish, and their children weren’t taught secular subjects either, the fact that the children don’t know too much English is not a reason to remove them from their parents.

    The Amish also dress differently than most people and teach their children their way of life and they are not condemned for it so why is this group being singled out?

    If this is the way these people want to live and they are being persecuted because of it, its called Anti-Semitism !!!

    12 years ago

    TO ALL ATTACKERS ON COMMENT #2 Here’s My Response: You Guys Know Very Well About Previous Generations about our Zaidys Bubbies BUT One thing You Forgot toAdd WHAT DID THE RABUNIM Of. Previous Generation Say?? It states Clear in Many Seforim their Clear Psak that in Talmod Torah & Yeshivas Shouldn’t be learned Lamidi Chol. And Not Only those This Sect do so But All Frum Chasidic Yeshivas Follow Das Torah. So PLEASE STOP BASHING THOSE PEOPLE! THEY’RE GREAT PEOPLE! PERIOD.

    12 years ago

    For all who claim the kids are “like the Amish or some native culture” the child protective services are not looking at all families- only 3. Hence, it is obvious it isn’t a cultural thing but a real concern of safety. These kids are apparently malnourished and neglected (neglect is a legal term here, not whether or not the parents were present in the house). This is terrible and should not be tolerated- the kids need protection!

    stamm
    stamm
    12 years ago

    I really don’t know what goes on there but it does break my heart to see little girls all dressed in black layers and burkas. is there any minhag or chumra that unmarried girls should cover their hair? Like these children cannot act like kids?

    TexasJew
    TexasJew
    12 years ago

    Put the adults in jail and give the children a chance of a normal life.
    These are all nut jobs.

    heimish
    heimish
    12 years ago

    This is not anti semitic. This is torture. I have a family member that has been through this horror.

    lazerx
    lazerx
    12 years ago

    “ultra-orthodox Jewish sect known as Lev Tahor”

    JEWISH? this is a group of Iranian loving meshumads who are trying to enjoy the best of both worlds. They want the modernity of the West (guy has a cell phone in pix) and the religious extremities of Islam. The traditions of Judaism doesn’t talk to them.

    Let them go to the Congo where no one will bother them and no one will eat them alive (maybe).

    shmielglassman
    shmielglassman
    12 years ago

    this is not monroe or skver or even kashu
    unfortunatly children dont choose their parents- these poor kids are messed up no matter whats done its lahavdil a tribe in ????
    no school/ no employment oppotunities/ marriage at 15/total seclusion ../ no connection to family/ burka ………
    no godol approves of this
    BUT I SEE THEY ARE VERY SAVVY HAVE LAWYERS AND WILL BEAT IT ” YEDER SHMOIGER FAR ZICH TOIG ER”
    where is the money coming from???? buses , hotels , leases….
    his son nusson left and thats where the info is coming from….
    al tifrosh min hatzibur how wise were our chachomim

    basmelech
    basmelech
    12 years ago

    I know which families are involved and their children are not malnourished or neglected. One of the mothers has a very anti Chareidi brother in E”Y and he has been a source of motzei shem rah on his own sister because he hates their community. He has never even been there to see the kids. It is wrong to take people’s kids away because they don’t speak English or French. That is absolutely ridiculous. Just because you don’t dress their way doesn’t mean they’re doing anything wrong. I am sure there are plenty of neglected malnourished children who dress fashionably so no one bothers them.

    SandmanNY
    SandmanNY
    12 years ago

    What personal experience do any of you here have with this group and its leadership? I see we have no shortage of opinion. But experience trumps opinion.

    Babishka
    Member
    Babishka
    12 years ago

    I feel terrible for these kids. You know that when (not even a question of “IF”) they go off the derech they will go COMPLETELY OFF THE DERECH and reject all kinds of Judaism.

    We are in golus and the way to properly deal with that is to accept the fact that we are in golus and exist in the goyishe/secular world while keeping the Torah halachos. We don’t withdraw from the world and we don’t adopt goyishe customs like dressing girls in a black cloak like the Muslims do.

    Unique89
    Unique89
    12 years ago

    I did not read through all comments just the first few and I was very disturbed. The aide cheraida from yerushalayim has come out against them. This is a CULT. It does not follow the toirah in any way. You are only allowed to learn what you want only what the rebbe is learning and if you learn something else you get punished. The info I know is not based on what I heard but from visiting them and asking a lot of questions from them themselves.

    The children that were taken away in the summer are thriving. They gained weight and are mainstreamed in a normal chassidishe home. Let’s hope the other parents wake up and leave for the sake of their kids.

    And to those saying that they are happy, it is not true. I know several people who are there only because their spouses are so brainwashed and they don’t want to lose custody of the kids. So they just stay.

    Facts1
    Facts1
    12 years ago

    “Youth protection investigators, on the other hand, claimed there was evidence of extreme neglect, malnutrition, and isolation when they inspected the children’s homes in Quebec. They also said the children, who are home schooled, cannot solve basic math problems or speak English or French.”

    All of the above applies to every Hasidic family, besides the malnutrition. They are being persecuted and I have nothing with that extremist sect.

    michaltastik_dot_com
    michaltastik_dot_com
    12 years ago

    As someone who has had lots of friends who have gone through foster care, the home they are being taken from is very doubtfully worse than the one to which they are going. Personally, I think most foster kids shouldn’t be pulled because many foster parents beat their foster kids. So, kids should only be pulled if it’s really bad like if they are being burned with cigarettes or something. If the government would spend money advising people how to be a parent and stop subsidizing welfare moms, we might have less abused kids.

    newtransplant
    newtransplant
    12 years ago

    Until schooling became compulsive they did indeed not go to school. Once schooling became mandatory they would all have known lanuages and mathematics. Thus, these children too have to be schooled according to the law of the land. There are many Jewish schools that are government approved and teach a reduced curriculum, the point here is that these children do not attend Any approved facility.