# Computer Replaces Razor For Rabbi's Prison Picture (Published 1994)

- Outlet: The New York Times
- Author: George James; The New York Times
- Date: 1994-12-29
- URL: https://www.nytimes.com/1994/12/29/nyregion/computer-replaces-razor-for-rabbi-s-prison-picture.html
- Retrieved via: wayback:20230918204652 on 2026-11-18 (https://web.archive.org/web/20230918204652/https://www.nytimes.com/1994/12/29/nyregion/computer-replaces-razor-for-rabbi-s-prison-picture.html)
- Language: en
- Words: 708

---

Supported by

# Computer Replaces Razor For Rabbi's Prison Picture

A conflict between a New York State prison regulation requiring that inmates be photographed clean-shaven and a religious belief that a man's beard must not be touched was resolved in Federal court yesterday through the latest computer technology.

For the first time, New York State accepted a computer-generated image of what an inmate, in this case, Rabbi Shlomo Helbrans, would look like without a beard instead of making him shave for a conventional photograph. The state requires that a bearded inmate be photographedshaven so that he can be more easily identified if he escapes and shaves off his beard.

The image was produced by Engineering Animation of Ames, Iowa, a company specializing in scientific computer animation, which was hired by Gerald L. Shargel, the lawyer for Rabbi Helbrans. "Through the use of state-of-the-art-computer technology," Mr. Shargel said, "we were able to enforce a biblical command."

The ruling was seen by Mr. Shargel and others involved in technology and religious-freedom issues as establishing a precedent, but the State Attorney General's office held that the decision applied only to this case.

Rabbi Helbrans, the leader of a small Hasidic sect, was sentenced to 4 to 12 years in prison last month for kidnapping Shai Fhima Reuven, a Jewish teen-ager who had been sent by his mother for bar mitzvah instruction at the rabbi's yeshiva.

Rabbi Helbrans fought on religious grounds in United States District Court in Manhattan to keep the prison system from shaving his beard. His lawyer, Mr. Shargel, cited Leviticus 19:27: "Ye shall not round the corners of your heads, neither shalt thou mar the corners of thy beard."

The state held that the shaving requirement for new prisoners was upheld by a 1984 Federal court ruling in the case of a Rastafarian prisoner. Mr. Shargel, however, felt that under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act passed by Congress in 1993, there was no compelling security reason for the government to shave his client's beard if a computer-generated likeness could be used.

He said he started with his neighborhood computer store and "just kept making calls" until a law professor at George Washington Law School recommended Engineering Animation.

Last week, the company sent its "visualization expert" and medical illustrator, Katherine Lattie, to Rikers Island, where the rabbi was in jail. She photographed and sketched front and profile views of his face.

But as a woman, under the rabbi's religious strictures, Ms. Lattie could not touch him. So she had Mr. Shargel use calipers and a ruler to measure the rabbi's face, then scanned photographs into the computer and, using visualization software, replicated his facial structure as it would look without beard and side curls.

In court yesterday, before- and after-beard images were shown on a monitor. After an expert studied them, the state accepted the computer likeness.

Mikki Seligman, a spokeswoman for the Attorney General, said no precedent had been set but that in the future computer-generated photos would be reviewed "on a case-to-case basis."

Mark Stern, a lawyer for the American Jewish Congress, said the "creative" resolution of the conflict was "a road map for every lawyer in the country who has one of these cases."

## Politics in the New York Region

- **Anti-Pollution Law:** Mayor Eric Adams has released proposed guidelines for Local Law 97, trailblazing climate legislation that limits fossil fuel emissions from large buildings. Not everyone is happy with the proposed rules.
- **Migrant Crisis:** Republicans appear to be testing whether New York’s influx of asylum seekers may prove as potent a political force in 2024 as crime was in 2022.
- **Democrats’ Primary Problem:** Ambitious New York Democrats eager to challenge Republicans defending House seats that President Biden won are creating primary pileups from Long Island to Syracuse.
- **Mayoral Election:** Liberal and progressive Democrats have made little secret of their dismay over the tenure of Adams. They are now openly strategizing how best to put forward a formidable challenger for 2025.
- **Housing:** Hochul has announced a series of executive actions designed to promote residential real estate development and ease the state’s housing crisis.

Advertisement
