NEW YORK, Nov. 22 -- A Brooklyn state Supreme Court judge sentenced Rabbi Shlomo Helbrans to between four and 12 years in prison Tuesday for the kidnapping of a teenage boy. Helbrans, of Monsey, N.Y., was convicted two weeks agoof second- degree kidnapping and fourth-degree conspiracy. He faced a maximum of eight to 25 years in prison for the abduction of Shai Fhima, now 15- years-old. Fhima disappeared in April 1992 after his mother, who is Jewish but not Orthodox, sent her son to Helbrans for bar mitzvah preparation. He surfaced in New York in February. Prosecutors contended that Helbrans, his wife Malka, and another man spirited Fhima out of Brooklyn, where he lived with his divorced mother, and eventually sent him to France because they wanted to give him a strict religious upbringing. Helbrans' attorney claimed the boy voluntarily ran away from an abusive home and stayed hidden of his own accord. Testifying before the jury, Fhima backed up the story. At the sentencing, Helbrans spoke on his own behalf and suggested that his religion was the issue in the trial. But Justice Thaddeus Owens, who is black, responded angrily, saying, 'Jews are not on trial here. Rabbis Helbrans is on trial. My ancestors were persecuted as much as the Jews.' In a statement following the sentencing, Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes said, 'I find no elation in Rabbi Helbrans being sent to prison, but the facts showed he had no legal right to interfere with the lawful parental custody of Hanna Fhima by taking her son.'
Malka Helbrans, who was acquitted of any involvement, said she was puzzled by the prosecution because her husband had only tried to help Fhima. 'We let this woman in our house. She said she will never forget our favors,' she said, as she was surrounded by supporters outside the courtroom. Hasidic Jews crowded into the courtroom to show their support for Helbrans. After the sentencing, Rabbi Steve Berkowitz called it 'an outrage.' 'It's a constitutional infringement of our freedom of religion,' he said. Rabbi Chaim Stauber said, 'This man is being scapegoated.' Fhima now lives with another rabbi. A Family Court judge originally awarded his parents custody, but after he ran away from home he was allowed to live with an Orthodox rabbi. Helbrans' alleged accomplice, Mordecai Weisz, has not yet been tried.





